Executions for desertion in World War I - The History Press (2024)

8th September, 2017 in Military

By David Johnson

The 302 British and Commonwealth soldiers executed for military offences committed while on active service on the Western Front cast a long shadow and their cases remain controversial to this day.

As shocking as that figure might be, it represents only 10 per cent of the 3,076 sentenced to death (in fact some 20,000 offences that could have attracted the death sentence were committed over this same period). These statistics show, therefore, that some of those executed were undoubtedly unlucky to be in the wrong place at the wrong time, when those further up the command chain saw a need to make an example of them, thereby making it something of a lottery for those concerned and therefore inherently unfair.

Those who volunteered for the army in August 1914, and those who joined afterwards, either as volunteers or as conscripts, left the civilian world behind them and found themselves in an alien environment, subject to what now seems, 100 years later, harsh military law which governed all aspects of the lives of the officers and soldiers in peace and in war, at home or overseas.

As a result of the outbreak of war, in September 1914 the normal system of military court martial was replaced by a system of summary court martial. Offences that carried the death penalty were then to be dealt with by a field general court martial presided over by a minimum of three officers, one of whom had to hold at least the rank of captain in order to act as president. All three had to be in agreement on any sentence passed. The recommended sentence was then passed up the chain of command, together with any mitigating circ*mstances and pleas for clemency.

The changes made in September 1914 are important because they allowed for the sentence, passed by the field general court martial, to be carried out within twenty-four hours – with no right of appeal. The reality for those sentenced to death was that the passage of time from sentence to its promulgation or announcement could be weeks if not months, whereas the time between promulgation and the actual execution was normally just a matter of a few hours.

On 8 September 1914 Private Thomas Highgate at the age of 17 became the first British soldier to be executed on the Western Front for desertion; just two days after sentence had been passed, proving that the process could be quick. In fact, the time between Private Highgate being informed of the confirmation of his sentence and his execution was just forty-five minutes.

Private Highgate served in the 1st Battalion of the Royal West Kents, which was one of the first elements of the British Expeditionary Force to land in France on 15 August 1914 and took part in the fighting at Mons. General Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien decided when confirming the sentence to make a very public example of Highgate and ordered that he ‘should be killed as publicly as possible’. As a result, he was executed in front of two companies of his comrades. Smith-Dorrien later justified this by claiming that, as a result, there were no further charges of desertion brought in his division and, therefore, deterrence worked.

From 1915 onwards, uncomfortable questions about the army’s use of the death penalty began to be asked in Parliament. In 1915, Under Secretary of State for War Harold Tennant, in answer to a direct question, confirmed that executions had taken place, but in July of that year he refused to confirm the number of death sentences passed, on the grounds that it would not be in the public interest. Over the subsequent years the questions were to continue.

Extracted fromExecuted at Dawnby David Johnson

5th June, 2024 in , Military

D-Day, the closely guarded secret that secured victory

‘Good God!’ I thought after being shown a map with a small area on it that we had taken back, ‘We’ve just taken part in D-Day!’ Flight Lieutenant Noble Frankland (DFC CB CBE) is one of those for whom 6th June 1944 might have been just another ‘ordinary day’ in the operational c…

22nd April, 2024 in Military,

A tale of two court cases

The thought arrived as I was hovering inside a crowded coffee shop directly opposite the Royal Courts of Justice on the Strand. Tables and bars pulsed with suited, brief cased, device-bashing professionals; the buzz from conversation being shouted and spoken into phones and faces…

3rd April, 2024 in Military

The attack on Épinal

And so, in the early morning of 11 May, 973 heavy bombers took off in fine weather from airfields across East Anglia. Their mission was Operation 350: to fly 500 miles across France to attack railway marshalling yards in Mulhouse, Épinal, Belfort and Chaumont, and an airfield at…

15th January, 2024 in Military, Women in History

Remembering Patricia Rorke: A remarkable woman who lived through World War II

Author of Remarkable Women of the Second World War, Victoria Panton Bacon, remembers Pat Rorke. Pat died on 9th December 2023, aged 100 years and five weeks. ‘After the war, you have to learn to live together, remember that you are all human … behind all the bare recounted facts…

18th October, 2023 in , Military

Nobody Lives Here: A wartime Jewish childhood

This memoir is a gripping and unusual account of a survivor of the Shoah in Holland. With impressively clear recall of his childhood and early teens – he was 11 at the outbreak of the war – Lex Lesgever writes of his years on the run and in hiding in Amsterdam and beyond. It is u…

15th August, 2023 in History, Military

Siege warfare in the Middle Ages

In the medieval era, pitched battles were risky affairs; the work of years could be undone in a single day thanks to the vagaries of weather, terrain or simple bad luck.C.B. Hanley author of theMediaeval Mystery series, including thelatest additionBlessed…

12th July, 2023 in , Military, True Crime

Why did the United States allow the worst war criminal into America?

Until I began researching the story of the teenager who risked his life to bring the ‘Butcher of the Balkans? to justice, I knew little of the atrocities committed in the Nazi puppet state of Croatia during the Second World War. I learned that I am far from alone. Most people I s…

23rd September, 2022 in Military

Black Poppies: Young Reader Edition

Dedicated chronicler of Black British history, Stephen Bourne explores the many and extraordinary ways in which black people helped Britain fight the Great War, on the battlefield and at home in this new illustrated edition of Black Poppies for children. ‘Publishers in Britain ar…

22nd June, 2022 in , Military, Women in History

Remarkable Women of the Second World War

If I may say so myself, as author of the twelve stories (and epilogue) about the Second World War contained in Remarkable Women of the Second World War, anyone with an insatiable appetite for knowledge about World War Two must read this book. It does not have to be read in…

19th May, 2022 in Military

Oradour-sur-Glane: An echo from history

As news spread of the Allied landings in Normandy, and thoughts turned to the liberation of their country, few throughout France could have predicted the fate of Oradour-sur-Glane, a community in Haute-Vienne, near the city of Limoges. On 10 June 1944 the inhabitants of the large…

26th January, 2022 in , Military

Norwich in the Second World War

Neil R. Storey author ofNorwich in the Second World Wartells the story of the city and its people, as far as possible, in the words of those who were actually there. When the acclaimed Norfolk author George Borrow described Norwich as ‘a fine old city’ in the nineteenth century…

9th June, 2021 in Military

From the fires of Oradour

10 June marks the anniversary of the Oradour-sur-Glane massacre. These identity documents were retrieved from the fire-ravaged remains of a home there. They were found by two Jewish sisters who miraculously survived the tragedy and belonged to their parents Robert and Carmen Pinè…

11th November, 2020 in Military

The final journey of the Unknown Warrior

11 November 2020 marked the centenary of the burial within Westminster Abbey of the Unknown Warrior. This was a British soldier who was killed in the First World War, someone who was originally buried in or near one of the many battlefields of the Western Front. The idea of comme…

14th October, 2020 in Military

The forgotten codebreakers of the First World War

The story of the British codebreaking centre at Bletchley Park during the Second World War is now justly famous. But Bletchley Park did not arise out of a vacuum. Part of the success of Bletchley Park between 1939 and 1945 was due to the success of the less renowned British codeb…

9th April, 2020 in Military

The Katyn Massacre: Deceitful diplomacy and mass murder

A confidential letter arrived at the Foreign Office from the British Embassy in Washington informing them that the American Committee had been formed to investigate the Katyn massacre of 1940. This committee was established largely through the efforts of Julius Epstein, a journal…

24th March, 2020 in Military

VE Day: Celebrating Victory in Europe

We think of VE Day as a time of mass celebration; jubilant crowds laughing, dancing and partying. And party they did – but the images shown below also record many whose physical and mental condition or sense of grief and loss would scar them for years to come… Browse our galler…

18th February, 2020 in Military

The Battle of Iwo Jima: Securing the beachhead

By 19 February 1945 Iwo Jima had already endured the longest and most intensive aerial attack delivered in the Pacific during the Second World War. It had started with a carrier raid in June 1944 and Seventh Air Force’s B-24 Liberator bombers stationed on the Marianas Islands beg…

11th November, 2019 in Maritime, Military

The sinking of Hitler’s battleship Tirpitz

‘Last night’s raid successful. Tirpitz sunk.’ On 13 November 1944, this announcement at No 5 Bomber Group’s staff conference signalled the end of four and a half years of air effort by the RAF and Fleet Air Arm. The 52,000 tons armoured German battleship with 15in guns capable of…

28th October, 2019 in Military

The Battle of Clonmult: The IRA’s worst defeat

On Sunday 20February 1921, during the Irish War of Independence, the flying column of the 4thBattalion, First Cork Brigade was wiped out after being surprised in their base camp by a British Army patrol. The resulting Battle of Clonmult was the IRA’s greatest loss of…

24th September, 2019 in Military

Flying a De Havilland 4 in World War I

Leave passed all too quickly, and when but ten of the preciousfourteen days were gone, a telegram came recallingme to the squadron. The great German offensive on theBritish Front had begun, and I was almost glad to go.A taxi drive to Filton, which happened…

14th August, 2019 in Military, , Women in History

Black women of World War One

With only a few exceptions, such as the Crimean war ‘doctress’ Mary Seacole, black women have been ‘written out’ of British history. This is true of the many books published about Britain and the First World War and yet it is possible to uncover life stories from this ‘hidden his…

5th June, 2019 in Military

D-Day: Before and after in images

A story of ingenuity and devastating loss of life, the moving history of D-Day – its impact and its cost – is capturedhere on film in vivid detail. Compiled from the Mirrorpix archives, this collection charts the detailed preparation, the brave action and the enduring after…

5th June, 2019 in Military

Codeword Overlord: Keeping D-Day top secret

Eighty years ago, on 6 June 1944, 168,000 Allied troops stormed ashore on the beaches of Normandy to begin the liberation of Nazi-occupied Europe, supported by 12,000 aircraft and nearly 7,000 ships. The invasion plan, initially codenamed Overlord and then designated Neptune and…

29th May, 2019 in , Military

The Last Cambridge Spy: John Cairncross

Throughout the 1930s, Soviet ‘illegals’ – resident agents operating in Britain – carefully selected, recruited and nurtured emerging talent at Britain’s ancient universities of Cambridge and, to a lesser extent, Oxford. After their graduation these recruits forged highflying care…

22nd March, 2019 in Military

The Great Escape from Stalag Luft 3

The escape of 76 POWs from Stalag Luft 3 on 24 March 1944 was the greatest mass escape from a prisoner-of-war camp ever known. It caused the Germans serious problems and great embarrassment, and tied up thousands of troops and civilians in a huge two week long search for the pris…

28th January, 2019 in , Military,

The Prison of Norman Cross: The Lost Town of Huntingdonshire

During the Napoleonic Wars many thousands of prisoners of war arrived in Britain often to languish in the war prisons for many years. Norman Cross Prison Depot, near Peterborough, was one of the largest with accommodation for up to 7,000 captives and used from 1797 until it close…

25th January, 2019 in Military

French Resistance and the Nazis’ attempt to tame ‘Little Russia’

When trying to make sense of the vast kaleidoscope of people, purposes and organisations that made up the French Resistance, it is often a good idea to break the country down into smaller parts. This is just what the F section of the Special Operations Executive (SOE), Churchill’…

14th January, 2019 in , Military, Women in History

Vera Eriksen: The Second World War’s most enigmatic spy

In September 1940 a beautiful young woman arrived by sea plane and rubber dinghy on the shores of Scotland accompanied by two men. It was to be yet another episode in the Germans’ attempt to penetrate British defences and infiltrate spies into the country. Of all the female spies…

29th November, 2018 in , Military

Churchill’s hidden years

Have you ever wondered what Churchill did in the First World War? Most people recall the Dardanelles. Some ask ‘Wasn’t he a soldier?’ But then they generally get stuck. I began to think about this and took a closer look. I was staggered to find both how active he was and how cont…

7th November, 2018 in , Military

Chapel Street: The bravest little street of World War I

In 1914, when the Great War broke out Chapel Street, Altrincham, Cheshire saw 161 men volunteer for duty from just 60houses. Chapel Street was a long and narrow cul-de-sac of Georgian and Victorian houses, it was home to a four hundred strong multi-cultural (Scottish, Welsh…